top of page

The One Mistake I Won't Make Again in My Coaching Business

4 hours ago
7 min read

I learned this lesson the hard way.

When I started mentoring, I was focused on one thing:

Give my 100%.

And I did.

I showed up for the sessions.

I shared resources.

I gave guidance.

I answered questions.

I helped create plans.

I provided feedback.

Most importantly, I genuinely wanted my mentee to succeed.


But one coaching experience taught me something I wish I had understood before starting my coaching business:

You can control the quality of your guidance. You cannot control someone else's execution.

That sounds obvious.


But when you're new to coaching, it is easy to believe that if you give enough value, support, time, and attention, your client will naturally get results.


That's not how it works.


Without execution, nothing works. When mentees will execute learnings, then only get outcome. And often a teacher become responsible for failures. After facing similar problem in my online mentoring, I learned the importance of coaching statement that is nothing but a written document that explains what the coach and the client are each responsible for, and what happens if the work is not done.


In this article, I'm going to share about this and other relevant concepts for you so you won't make same mistakes.


Why Do Coaching Clients Ask for a Refund?

Coaching clients can ask for refunds when results do not come and expectations were never defined. In my case, the problem was not a lack of guidance. It was a lack of implementation, and I had not written down that results depend on the client's action. Unclear agreements, not just weak coaching, can lead to refund requests.


My mentee had plans.

We discussed what needed to be done.

We created strategies and talked about the next steps.


But the real problem wasn't a lack of information.

It was implementation.


There were discussions.

There were plans.

There were delays.

There were reasons why things couldn't be done.

But there wasn't enough execution.


I kept asking her to take action. She kept delaying. I understand that pressure is a normal part of life. Personal life has ups and downs. That is real.


But we still have to learn how to manage both, even under pressure. Execution is where progress happens. Or doesn't. And eventually, the person asked for a refund. That conversation made me stop and think.


Was the problem my coaching?

Had I failed to provide enough guidance?

Had I not given enough resources?


The answer, from my perspective, was no. I knew I had given my best. When a student doesn't execute, the teacher often ends up carrying the blame. That is exactly what happened to me. But then I realized something even more important.


My mistake wasn't in the coaching. My mistake was in the agreement.


The Part I Failed to Define

I had never clearly stated my refund policy. More importantly, I had never clearly explained that the results of the program would depend on the mentee's implementation.


I had assumed this was obvious. It wasn't. And that was my responsibility.

As a coach or mentor, it isn't enough to know your boundaries.


You have to communicate them.

Your client cannot be expected to follow rules that were never clearly established.


I eventually returned some amount because I had empathy for the situation. But emotionally, it was difficult. Because I knew I had shown up fully. And I also knew something that every coach eventually has to accept:


You cannot manufacture results for someone who isn't willing to implement.


Who Is Responsible for Results in Coaching?

The coach owns the process. The client owns the execution. A coach is responsible for the quality of the service, the clarity of guidance, the program structure, and the support.


The client is responsible for implementation, consistency, effort, and follow-through. Guidance plus implementation equals progress.


And always remember: "A coach cannot do the client's work for them."


A Coaching Program Is Not a Vending Machine

This experience changed the way I think about running a coaching business.

A coaching program is not:

Pay → Attend sessions → Get results.


It is closer to:

Guidance + Implementation = Progress


A mentor can provide:

  • Strategy

  • Knowledge

  • Guidance

  • Feedback

  • Accountability

  • Resources

  • Support

  • A framework to follow


But the mentee has responsibilities too:

  • Implementation

  • Consistency

  • Effort

  • Practice

  • Follow-through

  • Willingness to learn

  • Taking action between sessions

This is where the responsibility has to be clearly divided.


The coach owns the process. The client owns the execution.

That doesn't mean a coach has no responsibility for outcomes.


A coach should absolutely take responsibility for the quality of their service, the clarity of their guidance, the structure of the program, and the support they provide.


But there is a boundary. A coach cannot do the client's work for them.


Why Do Some Mentees Get Results and Others Don't?

Mentees who take action get results. One of my recent mentees published a book and is doing great because she put in the effort. Another mentee had plans but kept delaying, and nothing moved. The guidance was the same. The execution was different, so the results were different. Without effort, results are not possible.


I have had a very different experience with my other mentees.


One of my recent mentees published her book.


She is doing great.

Not because she had more time.

Not because she had fewer problems.

Because she put in the effort.

She showed up, did the work, and finished what she started.


If you don't put in the effort, how is it possible to get the result?

It isn't. That is why I no longer measure a mentoring relationship by how much I give.

I measure it by what happens between the sessions.


What Should a Coaching Agreement Include?

A coaching agreement should state five things before the client starts: what the coach is responsible for, what the client is responsible for, what is required for the program to work, what happens when implementation does not happen, and the refund and cancellation policy. Share it in writing before payment or enrollment, not after a problem occurs.


This experience has changed how I run my coaching business, including how I structure my programs and services.


Going forward, I will clearly define five things before a client starts:


1. What I am responsible for

The client should know exactly what they will receive from me.

This includes sessions, guidance, feedback, resources, frameworks, support, and whatever else is part of the program.


2. What the client is responsible for

The client also needs to understand what is expected from them.

If the program requires writing, publishing, practicing, implementing a strategy, completing assignments, or taking specific actions, that should be stated clearly.


3. What is required for the program to work

This is perhaps the most important part. A program doesn't exist in isolation.

Its effectiveness depends on how the client participates in it.

So expectations around participation and implementation should be discussed before the program begins.


4. What happens when implementation doesn't happen

There should be no ambiguity here.

If a client doesn't complete the work, misses sessions, ignores agreed actions, or doesn't implement the strategy, both sides should already understand what that means for the program.


5. The refund and cancellation policy

This should never be left to assumption. The policy should be written clearly and shared before payment or enrollment. Not after a problem occurs.

Want to see how I run my programs? Explore the {INTERNAL_LINK_1: HybridWrite™ mentorship program}.

Why Clear Expectations Matter

At first, I thought putting all these things in writing might make a coaching relationship feel too formal.

Now I think the opposite.

Clear expectations create better relationships.

When both sides know what they are responsible for, there is less room for misunderstanding.

The client knows what they are getting.

The coach knows what they are expected to deliver.

And both understand what is required from the other side.


This isn't about protecting the coach at the expense of the client.

It is about creating a fair agreement for both.

The Lesson Goes Beyond Coaching


This isn't only a lesson for coaches. It applies to almost anyone who sells expertise.

If you're a:

  • Coach

  • Mentor

  • Consultant

  • Freelancer

  • Trainer

  • Strategist

  • Service provider

you should think beyond:

"What am I going to deliver?"

Also ask:

"What does the other person need to do for this service to create value?"

Because expertise alone doesn't create outcomes.

Execution matters.

And sometimes the person paying for your expertise is also responsible for turning that expertise into action.

Selling your expertise through writing? Read {INTERNAL_LINK_2: article on writing that attracts clients}.


Don't Assume. Define.

That's probably the biggest lesson I took from this experience.

Never assume your client understands the rules of engagement. Put them in writing.


Don't assume they know:

  • What the program includes.

  • What it doesn't include.

  • What they need to do.

  • What happens if they don't participate.

  • How results should be evaluated.

  • What your refund policy is.

  • Where your responsibility ends.


Make it clear before you begin.

Because clarity at the beginning can prevent difficult conversations later.


The Biggest Takeaway

One of the hardest lessons in a service business is realizing that giving your best doesn't guarantee that someone else will get the result they want.


You can prepare thoroughly.

You can teach well.

You can provide the right resources.

You can answer questions.

You can create the strategy.

You can support someone throughout the process.


But ultimately, the other person has to take action.

That's not a failure of coaching.

That's the nature of coaching.

And that's why the next version of my coaching programs will have clearer expectations, clearer responsibilities, and clearer policies from day one.


Because I don't want my clients to wonder what is expected of them.

And I don't want myself to wonder where my responsibility ends.


Your expertise can create the path.

But you cannot walk it for your client.

And that is one business lesson I won't make the same way again.


This is my experience, not legal advice. Talk to a lawyer before you finalize your contract.


Building your own coaching business and want a second pair of eyes on your offer? Book a session with me at topmate.io/vibha_soni 

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Writing Isn't About Content. It's About Thinking.

Learn why clear thinking matters more than writing skills. Most professionals write without clarity because they haven't done the thinking work first. Discover the system that transforms unclear commu

 
 
 

Comments


About

Services

© 2023 by Vibha Soni

All Rights Reserved

  • Vibha Soni LinkedIn
  • Vibha Soni Instagram

Insights

bottom of page